What is the purpose of an independent design review?

A review gives project stakeholders a separate assessment of the proposed fire protection design. Its value depends on a clear question: for example, whether a submission addresses the specified design criteria, whether key information is missing, or whether proposed changes need further justification.

It is useful to arrange the review while comments can still inform project decisions. For an existing building, first establish whether the question concerns the original design, an alteration or the suitability of protection for a changed use. A document review and an on-site inspection should be distinguished in the appointment.

Agree the design basis before checking the drawings

The reviewer needs to know the building’s use, the protection objectives, the systems included and the standards, editions and other requirements specified for the project. Record which documents establish that basis and who is responsible for resolving conflicting instructions.

For a sprinkler design using NFPA 13, that standard addresses sprinkler design, installation and acceptance testing. Where FM criteria are specified, identify the relevant FM Property Loss Prevention Data Sheets. These references have defined purposes; listing several standards without explaining their application does not establish a coherent design basis.

The selected standard’s latest publication date does not, by itself, establish the edition required by a particular contract, insurer or authority. Confirm that basis for the actual project.

Which documents should be submitted?

Provide a controlled package with drawing numbers, revision identifiers and dates. For a sprinkler review, useful inputs include:

  • A project brief and the agreed design criteria.
  • Layout drawings, relevant sections and sprinkler details.
  • Hydraulic calculations and the water-supply information on which they rely.
  • Equipment data sheets and relevant pump information.
  • Building use, ceiling details and storage information relevant to the protection approach.
  • Earlier review comments, proposed deviations and responses from the designer.

FM’s plan-review checklist illustrates the importance of drawings, calculations, material information, water-supply evidence and occupancy or storage details. It is a useful reference when preparing a submission, rather than a universal replacement for the reviewer’s project-specific document request.

What can the reviewer examine?

Within the agreed scope, the review can examine whether the submission explains its design assumptions, whether the drawings and calculations are coordinated, and whether the specified equipment and water-supply information support the proposed approach. Missing information should become a recorded question, rather than an assumed favourable answer.

The review should also identify its boundaries. Specify whether it includes calculation verification, particular interfaces with other systems, a site visit, or a check of a revised submission. A review of one system does not establish the adequacy of every element of the building’s fire strategy.

What should the deliverables look like?

Agree the output before work starts. A practical review package can include a submission register, a schedule of comments, marked-up drawings where appropriate, identified information gaps and a statement of scope and limitations.

Each comment should be traceable to a document or issue. Give it a reference, explain what needs clarification or correction, record the designer’s response and identify the evidence needed to close it. Revision control matters: a resolved comment against an earlier drawing does not automatically describe the final issue.

Confirm whether checking responses or reviewing another revision is included in the appointment. That makes the distinction between an initial review and a completed comment-resolution process clear to everyone involved.

How does a review relate to approval and installation?

Agree responsibilities among the client, designer, reviewer, installer, insurer and relevant authority. The review appointment should define its authority; do not assume that a third-party report replaces another party’s required acceptance or relieves the designer of their design responsibilities.

A design review examines the submitted information. Whether the installed system matches that information is a separate question requiring the relevant inspection, commissioning or acceptance activities. Our fire sprinkler inspection guide explains how to define an assessment of an existing system.

Frequently asked questions

When should a third-party review start?

Once there is a clear design brief and a sufficiently developed submission to assess. Agree a review stage early enough for findings to inform project decisions before affected work proceeds.

Does a review include redesign?

Only if that work is expressly included in the appointment. Independent review comments, design changes and verification of revised documents should have clearly allocated responsibilities.

Can a review proceed with missing information?

A limited review may be possible, but missing inputs and the conclusions they prevent should be recorded. It should not be presented as an unrestricted review of a complete design.

Sources and further reading

These links provide background to the topics discussed. Confirm the applicable standard, edition and project requirements for the particular appointment.